Decoding FMCSA's Safety Measurement System (SMS)

Introduction: Is Your Fleet Safe? Understanding FMCSA's SMS

Running a trucking company or managing a fleet comes with immense responsibility, especially when it comes to safety. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) uses a powerful tool called the Safety Measurement System (SMS) to keep our roads safe. But what exactly is the SMS, and how does it impact your business?

This blog post breaks down the FMCSA's SMS, explaining how it works, what data it uses, and how it prioritizes motor carriers for interventions. We'll cover everything from the BASICs to intervention thresholds, giving you actionable insights to improve your safety scores and avoid costly penalties. By the end, you'll understand how to navigate the SMS and ensure your fleet is operating safely and compliantly.

What is the Safety Measurement System (SMS)?

The Safety Measurement System (SMS) is the FMCSA's core data-driven system for identifying motor carriers that pose the greatest safety risk. Think of it as a sophisticated risk assessment tool that analyzes a carrier's safety performance based on data collected from roadside inspections, crash reports, and investigations. The goal? To focus FMCSA's limited resources on the carriers that need the most attention, ultimately reducing accidents and saving lives.

SMS's Primary Functions:

• Identify High-Risk Carriers: Pinpoint carriers with potential safety problems that warrant intervention.
• Evaluate Safety Deficiencies: Determine the root causes of safety issues within a carrier's operations.
• Recommend Corrective Actions: Suggest remedies and encourage carriers to take proactive steps to improve safety.
• Enforce Compliance: Impose penalties on non-compliant carriers when necessary to ensure adherence to safety regulations.

Diving Deep: How SMS Analyzes Safety Data

The SMS doesn't just pull numbers out of thin air. It meticulously analyzes safety data from the past 24 months, creating a comprehensive picture of a carrier's safety performance. This data includes:

• Roadside Inspection Results: Details from inspections conducted by state and federal officials, noting any violations or safety concerns.
• Crash Reports: Information on accidents involving the carrier's vehicles, including details about the cause and severity.
• Investigation Findings: Results from FMCSA investigations into a carrier's operations, uncovering potential systemic safety issues.

This data is then organized into seven Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs). Let's take a closer look at each one:

1. Unsafe Driving: Speeding, reckless driving, improper lane changes, and other unsafe driving behaviors.
   • Actionable Advice: Implement driver training programs focused on safe driving techniques and monitor driver behavior using telematics systems.
2. Crash Indicator: Historical crash involvement based on crash reports.
   • Actionable Advice: Analyze crash reports to identify trends and implement preventative measures, such as improved driver training or vehicle maintenance.
3. Hours-of-Service (HOS) Compliance: Violations of HOS regulations, including exceeding driving time limits and failing to take required breaks.
   • Actionable Advice: Utilize electronic logging devices (ELDs) to accurately track driver hours and ensure compliance with HOS regulations.
4. Vehicle Maintenance: Issues related to vehicle maintenance, such as defective brakes, lights, or tires.
   • Actionable Advice: Establish a comprehensive vehicle maintenance program with regular inspections and timely repairs.
5. Controlled Substances/Alcohol: Violations related to drug and alcohol use, including positive drug tests and alcohol-related offenses.
   • Actionable Advice: Implement a robust drug and alcohol testing program and provide education on the dangers of substance abuse.
6. Hazardous Materials (HM) Compliance: Violations of HM regulations, including improper packaging, labeling, and transportation of hazardous materials.
   • Actionable Advice: Provide specialized training for drivers and personnel involved in the transportation of hazardous materials.
7. Driver Fitness: Issues related to driver qualifications, such as invalid licenses or medical certificates.
   • Actionable Advice: Verify driver qualifications regularly and ensure drivers meet all FMCSA requirements.

Scoring and Prioritization: How SMS Ranks Carriers

For each BASIC, the SMS follows a three-step process:

1. Measure Calculation: Calculates a measure of the carrier's performance in that BASIC based on the available data.
2. Grouping: Groups carriers with similar numbers of safety events to create peer groups.
3. Ranking and Percentile Assignment: Ranks carriers within their peer group and assigns a percentile score from 0 to 100, with higher scores indicating worse performance.

Carriers exceeding FMCSA Intervention Thresholds in one or more BASICs may be prioritized for interventions. These thresholds vary depending on the carrier type:

• General Carriers: Have different thresholds than passenger or hazardous materials carriers.
• Passenger Carriers: Typically face stricter thresholds due to the higher risk associated with transporting passengers.
• Hazardous Materials Carriers: Also face stricter thresholds due to the potential for catastrophic consequences in the event of an accident.

FMCSA Interventions: What Happens When a Carrier is Flagged?

When a carrier's SMS scores trigger intervention thresholds, the FMCSA has a range of tools at its disposal:

1. Early Contact:
   • Warning Letters: Informing the carrier of potential safety issues and urging them to take corrective action.
   • Targeted Roadside Inspections: Focusing inspections on specific areas of concern identified by the SMS.
2. Investigations:
   • Offsite Investigation: Reviewing a carrier's records and data remotely to assess their safety performance.
   • Onsite Focused Investigation: Conducting an onsite investigation focused on specific areas of concern.
   • Onsite Comprehensive Investigation: Conducting a thorough onsite investigation of all aspects of the carrier's operations.
3. Follow-On:
   • Cooperative Safety Plan: Working with the carrier to develop a plan to improve their safety performance.
   • Notice of Violation: Issuing a notice of violation for non-compliance with safety regulations.
   • Notice of Claim: Seeking financial penalties for violations of safety regulations.
   • Operation Out of Service Order: Ordering the carrier to cease operations due to serious safety concerns.

The Impact: How Effective are SMS Interventions?

The FMCSA uses the Carrier Intervention Effectiveness Model (CIEM) to measure the impact of its interventions. By comparing crash rates before and after an intervention, the CIEM estimates the number of crashes, injuries, and fatalities prevented. In fiscal year 2021, the model estimated that interventions prevented 11,305 crashes, 5,599 injuries, and 370 fatalities. This demonstrates the significant impact of the SMS in improving road safety.

What's New? Recent and Upcoming Changes to SMS

The FMCSA is constantly working to improve the SMS and make it more effective. Recent and upcoming changes include:

• Consolidating Violations: Reducing the number of violation groups from 959 to 116 to simplify the system.
• Simplifying Severity Weights: Adjusting the violation severity weight scale from 1-10 to 1-2 to make it easier to understand.
• Adjusting Intervention Thresholds: Fine-tuning intervention thresholds for certain categories to better identify high-risk carriers.
• Focusing on Recent Violations: Giving more weight to violations that have occurred within the past 12 months.

These changes aim to improve the accuracy, fairness, and clarity of the SMS, ensuring that FMCSA resources are allocated effectively to address the most pressing safety risks.

Conclusion: Take Control of Your Safety Scores

The FMCSA's Safety Measurement System (SMS) is a critical tool for ensuring the safety of our nation's roads. By understanding how the SMS works, what data it uses, and how it prioritizes carriers for interventions, you can take proactive steps to improve your safety scores and avoid costly penalties. Implement robust safety programs, prioritize vehicle maintenance, and ensure driver compliance with all regulations. By doing so, you can create a safer operating environment for your drivers, your company, and the public.

Stay Informed and Engaged

• What are your biggest challenges in maintaining good SMS scores?
• Share your tips for improving safety performance in the comments below!
• Subscribe to our blog for more insights on transportation safety and compliance.

Further Reading

• FMCSA Safety Measurement System (SMS)
• CSA Interventions - Department of Transportation
• Carrier Intervention Effectiveness Model - A&I online